.

Legal Developments in the World of Trademarks, Copyrights, Advertising, and Beyond

Copyrights

A Tale of Two Princes

April 5, 2021

by Bruce R. Ewing

Download as a PDF

Share this page

An important decision by the Second Circuit in The Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, Case No. 19-2420-cv (2d Cir. Mar. 26, 2021), has, in important respects, upended how the defense of fair use is applied in copyright cases, with potentially major ramifications that transcend the “appropriation art” with which Warhol is concerned. Indeed, in many respects, the Warhol decision, in which a series of works created by the late artist Andy Warhol based on photographs of the late singer Prince were deemed not to be shielded by principles of fair use as a matter of law, is a repudiation in all but name of the same court’s decision in Cariou v. Prince, 714 F.3d 694 (2d Cir. 2013), in which most of a series of appropriation artworks created by the artist Richard Prince were deemed permissible fair uses of copyrighted, preexisting photographs taken by another artist.

The facts of Warhol are not complicated, and The TMCA first covered the case here.

In 1981, the photographer Lynn Goldsmith took the photo below of the iconic singer Prince as part of an assignment for Newsweek, back when news magazines were a thing. The record indicates that this particular photograph was never published.

In 1984, Goldsmith licensed her photo to Vanity Fair magazine for use as an “artist reference,” i.e., as a basis for a new work an unnamed artist would create that Vanity Fair would publish. Warhol turned out to be the artist, and his new work was published later that year, as shown below.

However, unbeknownst to Goldsmith, Warhol took Goldsmith’s photo and also used it to create a series of fourteen additional works, dubbed the “Prince Series,” some of which appear below.

Following Warhol’s death, the works that embody the Prince Series were either sold to third parties or sent to the Warhol Museum in Pittsburgh for display, and the Warhol Foundation regularly licensed them for commercial use. In 2018, following Prince’s death, Goldsmith allegedly learned for the first time of the existence of the Prince Series and the Warhol Foundation’s licensing of the Prince Series without any credit to her underlying work, or payment for its use.

After Goldsmith sent a letter asserting claims of copyright infringement, the Warhol Foundation filed an action in the Southern District of New York seeking a declaration of non-infringement based on fair use. Goldsmith counterclaimed for infringement. The district court granted summary judgment to the Foundation on its fair use defense, holding that all four factors set forth in 17 U.S.C. § 107 bearing on the issue of fair use favored the Foundation, in that the Prince Series was: (1) “transformative” because, while Goldsmith’s photo portrayed Prince as “not a comfortable person” and a “vulnerable human being,” the Prince Series portrayed Prince as an “iconic, larger-than-life figure”; (2) although Goldsmith’s photo was both creative and unpublished, which would traditionally weigh in Goldsmith’s favor, this was “of limited importance because the Prince Series works are transformative works”; (3) in creating the Prince Series, Warhol removed nearly all of the Goldsmith photo’s protectible elements; and (4) the Prince Series was not a market substitute that harmed or had the potential to harm Goldsmith.

On appeal, the Second Circuit rejected all of these conclusions, held that the Prince Series was neither transformative nor a fair use as a matter of law, and also concluded that the Goldsmith photo and Prince Series were substantially similar as a matter of law. As a result, if the Second Circuit’s decision stands, it is hard to see how the Warhol Foundation has any remaining defenses left to Goldsmith’s claim of infringement.

The core of the appellate decision is its conclusion that the Prince Series is not transformative. According to the court in Warhol, where a secondary work like the Prince Series “does not obviously comment on or relate back to the original or use the original for a purpose other than that for which it was created,” the bare assertion of a “higher or different artistic use,” is insufficient to render a work transformative. Instead, in order to be transformative, “the secondary work itself must reasonably be perceived as embodying an entirely distinct artistic purpose, one that conveys a ‘new meaning or message’ entirely separate from its source material.” Elaborating, the court held that “the secondary work’s transformative purpose and character must, at a bare minimum, comprise something more than the imposition of another artist’s style on the primary work such that the secondary work remains both recognizably deriving from, and retaining the essential elements of, its source material.”

The Prince Series flunked this test. While acknowledging that the Prince Series embodied “the distinct aesthetic sensibility that many would immediately associate with Warhol’s signature style – the elements of which are absent from the Goldsmith photo,” the court concluded that the Prince Series retained the essential elements of the Goldsmith photo without significantly adding to or altering the elements that made Goldsmith’s work distinctive. “Warhol’s modifications serve chiefly to magnify some elements of [Goldsmith’s photo] and minimize others. While the cumulative effect of those alterations may change the Goldsmith Photograph in ways that give a different impression of its subject, the Goldsmith Photograph remains the recognizable foundation upon which the Prince Series is built.” And it is “entirely irrelevant,” according to the Second Circuit, that most people looking at the Prince Series would identify it as a work of Warhol. “Entertaining that logic would inevitably create a celebrity-plagiarist privilege; the more established the artist and the more distinct that artist’s style, the greater leeway that artist would have to pilfer the creative labors of others. But the law draws no such distinctions.”

The Second Circuit’s conclusions in Warhol on the issue of whether the Prince Series is transformative stand in stark contrast to that court’s prior holding in Cariou, in which the work shown below on the left, from the artist Richard Prince, was deemed transformative of the photo on the right.

Why Richard Prince’s addition in his work of a guitar and three blobs obscuring the face of the original photo’s subject was deemed to be transformative as a matter of law, but Warhol’s addition of colors, the removal of depth and contrast, and other changes made to Goldsmith’s photo were not transformative as a matter of law, is an issue the Warhol decision did not address specifically. But while it took pains in Warhol to state that “we remain bound by Cariou, and have no occasion or desire to question its correctness on its own facts,” the Second Circuit made clear in Warhol that the Cariou approach to whether a secondary work qualifies as transformative no longer applies.

One other notable aspect of the Warhol decision is its treatment of the fourth fair use factor – the effect of the allegedly infringing use on the market for the original. While concluding that the primary markets for the original Prince Series and original Goldsmith photo (museums, art buyers) were different, the court found that the secondary licensing market for both works was the same, in that both parties’ works were of interest to magazines and other publications supplying content regarding Prince. This last fair use factor was characterized as “undoubtedly the single most important element of fair use” by the Supreme Court in Harper & Row Publishers, Inc. v. Nation Enters., 471 U.S. 539, 566 (1985), and the court’s conclusions on this factor in Warhol amplified its overall conclusion that the Prince Series was not shielded by principles of fair use. Indeed, the concurring opinion of Judge Sullivan in Warhol advocates a different approach to fair use, one that reduces the importance of whether a secondary work is transformative, in favor of an approach where the factor concerned with market effects is given greater attention. According to Judge Sullivan, such an approach would better serve the purposes of copyright and avoid the tendency of courts to collapse all four fair use factors into one inquiry: whether a secondary work is transformative.

So what’s next? Well, given Warhol’s prolific use of photographs of celebrities such as Marilyn Monroe, Elizabeth Taylor, Michael Jackson and John Lennon as source material for secondary works that are, qualitatively, very similar to the Prince Series, it may see future copyright claims from the photographers who created those images. And for other litigants in the Second Circuit who seek to mount a fair use defense on the ground that their allegedly infringing works are transformative, and thereby shielded by principles of fair use, their burden on that issue is now materially higher.

Related Categories:

Copyrights

Firm Highlights

Insights

Minnesota Consumer-Fraud Enforcement: Disclaimers Won’t Cure Deception, and Penalties Can Add Up

Misleading advertising claims can lead to costly consequences. In State of Minnesota ex rel. Ellison v. Wall & Associates, Inc., No. A25-2064, 2026 WL 3118291 (Minn. App. Oct. 19, 2026), the Minnesota Court of Appeals recently affirmed a bench trial verdict against a tax-relief company and two executives for violations of the Minnesota Consumer Fraud Act (“MCFA”) and the Minnesota Deceptive Trade Practices Act (“MDTPA”). The decision, which affirmed a substantial restitution and civil penalty judgment, underscores the broad power of the Minnesota Attorney General to act against deceptive sales practices. The decision also offers practical lessons for businesses seeking to reduce liability risks in consumer-facing communications. Background Wall & Associates (“W&A”), a Virginia-based tax-relief company, marketed assistance to taxpayers seeking relief from outstanding federal and state tax liabilities, often with offers in compromise—agreements to settle tax liabilities for less than the amount owed. In its extensive advertising campaigns, W&A represented that its average client received a 90% reduction in their tax debt, that it was a local company with Minnesota offices, that it provided legal services, and that it would “Solve ALL Tax Problems.” In reality, W&A’s promises bore little resemblance to what many clients received. Most of W&A’s clients saw just a 9.5% reduction in federal tax debt and 1.2% in state tax debt. W&A had no permanent Minnesota offices. And W&A provided neither legal representation nor assistance with filing tax returns—those services required referrals to separate firms for an additional fee. All the while, W&A clients paid upfront and recurring fees, including during periods when W&A did no work on their cases. Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison sued W&A, its founder and owner Ernest Kenneth Wall, and its president and CEO Patrick Mark Yates, alleging violations of, among other laws, the MCFA and the MDTPA. Following a 12-day bench trial, the district court determined that W&A violated the MCFA and MDTPA through its false and embellished advertising. The district court also held Wall and Yates individually liable for those violations because they directed, participated in, and acquiesced in the violations. The district court ordered injunctive relief, $2.7 million in restitution (with Wall and Yates jointly and severally liable for $1.3 million), and civil penalties of $786,517 against W&A, $415,500 against Wall, and $207,750 against Yates. The district court also awarded over $2.5 million in attorneys’ fees and costs to the state. W&A, Wall, and Yates appealed to the Minnesota Court of Appeals, which affirmed the district court’s decision on October 19, 2026. Although W&A, Wall, and Yates challenged the judgment on numerous grounds, several highlights of the decision provide important takeaways for consumer-facing businesses. Individual Reliance Is Not Required for Statutory Liability W&A argued that Attorney General Ellison had to prove a causal nexus between each violation of the MCFA and MDTPA and the injury to a particular consumer to establish liability. In W&A’s view, this required proof that each injured consumer had personally relied on W&A’s false representation. The Court of Appeals rejected this argument based on the MCFA’s and MDTPA’s plain language, which requires no proof of actual deception or confusion by consumers. The Court of Appeals finally pointed to the Minnesota Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Minnesota School of Business, Inc., which held that when a defendant’s misrepresentations are directed at and affected “a broad group of consumers, proof of direct individual reliance is not required to establish a causal nexus between MCFA violations and the harm suffered by consumers.” 935 N.W.2d 124, 135 (Minn. 2019). The Court of Appeals affirmed, however, that a causal nexus is necessary to support an award of damages under the MCFA and MDTPA. In making that determination, district courts look to various factors, including whether the misrepresentations were “longstanding, pervasive, and widespread in communications directed to consumers,” whether the seller intended and understood that consumers would rely on the misrepresentations, and whether the information was of a kind on which consumers would typically rely. The Court of Appeals’ decision continues Minnesota School of Business’s broad interpretation of liability under the MCFA and the MDTPA. Coordinated marketing campaigns to a “broad group of consumers” may expose businesses to MCFA and MDTPA liability without customer-by-customer proof of injury. That said, a causal nexus remains an element of an MCFA and MDTPA claim, and businesses involved in litigation should build a clear record at trial and on appeal showing how each of the relevant factors bears on the causal-nexus inquiry. Contractual Disclaimers Are Not an Automatic Defense to a Misleading Pitch W&A next argued that disclaimers in its client contracts prevented consumers from claiming they had been misled by its advertising. Reiterating that individual reliance is not required under the MCFA and MDTPA, the Court of Appeals held that a contractual disclaimer does not necessarily defeat a claim based on a conflicting oral representation. And on the facts of this case, the Court of Appeals agreed with the district court that W&A’s contractual disclaimers were insufficient given the extensive misrepresentations by W&A and the unequal bargaining power between it and its customers. This holding confirms that contractual disclaimers are not a cure-all for misleading advertising or sales practices. Businesses should review the entire customer journey, including pre-contract representations, as those representations may survive a contractual disclaimer to the contrary. And if faced with litigation, businesses should build a strong record, both at trial and on appeal, showing why any disclaimer is effective in context. The State Has Broad Authority to Seek Restitution W&A also challenged Attorney General Ellison’s authority to seek restitution under the state’s parens patriae authority to protect residents’ collective interests, arguing that injury to only 228 Minnesotans did not affect a sufficiently substantial segment of the population. The Court of Appeals rejected a simple headcount approach, instead explaining that the state had a legitimate interest in protecting residents’ economic well-being as a whole. In any event, the Court of Appeals held that if restitution was not appropriate under the state’s parens patriae authority, then it would still be appropriate under the Attorney General’s enforcement powers under Minn. Stat. § 8.31. The decision reinforces that the broader and more sustained the deceptive advertising, the stronger the case for restitution to protect Minnesotans’ economic interests. Civil Penalties Accrue Per Violation, Not Per Defendant The Court of Appeals finally rejected W&A’s claim that the Attorney General’s enforcement powers under Minn. Stat. § 8.31 permit only civil penalties of up to $25,000 for each defendant. Rather, the Court of Appeals explained that penalties are limited to $25,000 per violation. Multiple violations can therefore produce substantially greater penalties. The Court of Appeals also rejected the argument that restitution made penalties unnecessary: repaying consumers does not eliminate the need to address gains from deceptive conduct and deter future violations. Final Takeaways Align every consumer-facing communication. Broad and extensive marketing campaigns can expose businesses to stronger enforcement standards under the MCFA and MDTPA, making it critical that consumer communications remain accurate and consistent from the first advertisement through the final sale. Plan for layered enforcement exposure. Penalties under the MCFA and MDTPA can add up quickly: W&A, Wall, and Yates ultimately faced more than $6 million in civil penalties, restitution, and attorneys’ fees. The decision continues a line of Minnesota cases recognizing the Attorney General’s broad consumer-protection authority. Details matter. Although the Attorney General’s enforcement power is broad, it is not boundless. As the Court of Appeals explained, issues of causation, the effectiveness of contractual disclaimers, and the availability of restitution and civil penalties all turn on the specific facts of the case. Effective advocacy at trial and on appeal is critical to developing the facts relevant to liability and damages.