.

Legal Developments in the World of Trademarks, Copyrights, Advertising, and Beyond

Copyrights

The Second Circuit Shuts Down Application of First Sale Doctrine

December 27, 2018

by Jeffrey R. Cadwell

Download as a PDF

Share this page

In a decision issued on December 12, 2018, the Second Circuit refused to recognize application of the first sale doctrine to a service that had been established as a marketplace for resale of digital music files.  Under the first sale doctrine (set forth in Section 109(a) of the Copyright Act), owners of legally-obtained copies of copyrighted works can resell those copies without violating the rights of the copyright holder.  This is the reason we have stores and websites that focus on the sale of secondhand books, CDs, and other physical media.

The Second Circuit’s case involved ReDigi, which was an internet platform established in 2009 to allow the resale of digital music files that had been lawfully purchased on iTunes.  The ReDigi platform featured a mechanism for effecting transfer of a seller’s digital music file so that once the file was transferred to ReDigi’s server, it would be deleted from the uploader’s device.  According to ReDigi, its software ensured that there was never a complete version of the digital music file in two places at the same time.  The process would then be replicated to transfer the file from ReDigi’s server to a buyer’s device.  ReDigi’s software also continuously monitored an uploader’s computer and connected devices to detect duplicate files.  If duplicate files were found, ReDigi could suspend a user’s account.

Capitol Records, Capitol Christian Music Group, and Virgin Records sued ReDigi for copyright infringement in 2012.  The district court for the Southern District of New York found in favor of the plaintiffs and awarded $3.5 million in damages.  In affirming the judgment, the Second Circuit concluded that ReDigi’s service violated the copyright owners’ exclusive rights of reproduction under the Copyright Act.

In an opinion authored by Judge Pierre Leval, the Second Circuit acknowledged that ReDigi was acting in good faith in developing its platform, and was “not making efforts in the shadows to infringe on copyrights.”  The key problem for the court is that the first sale doctrine as codified in the Copyright Act relates to distribution of copyrighted works and not to reproduction of those works.  Accordingly, because the Second Circuit determined that the ReDigi platform creates a reproduction of the music file, the first sale doctrine was inapplicable.  Despite ReDigi’s argument that its technology ensured the complete music file never existed in two places simultaneously, the court concluded that “each transfer of a digital music file to ReDigi’s server and each new purchaser’s download of a digital music file to his device creates new [copies].”  The court also seemed particularly concerned that there would be no way to ensure the seller of a music file did not retain a copy.  For example, if a user had copied the file to an external hard drive prior to uploading the file to ReDigi’s server and the user never again attached the external hard drive to the user’s computer, ReDigi would not find the duplicate copy.

The Second Circuit did not, however, shut the door completely on application of the first sale doctrine in the digital context, acknowledging that “other technology may exist or be developed that could lawfully effect a first sale.”  The court posits that a person could place digital song files on a thumb drive and sell the thumb drive and it also cites William Patry’s copyright treatise for the observation that the first sale doctrine would permit sale of an iPod that contains lawfully made digital music files.  (In the author’s opinion, neither of these options addresses the court’s key holding that the first sale doctrine is inapplicable when reproduction of the digital music files is involved.  In fact, both of the examples given by the court most likely involve a reproduction of the file before the sale occurs.  In the thumb drive example, unless the owner originally downloaded the song files directly to the thumb drive, the act of placing the songs on the thumb drive before selling the songs requires reproduction of the song files.  Likewise, the typical manner in which users transfer songs to their iPods (or now, more likely, their iPhones) is to download the songs from iTunes onto their computer or an external hard drive and then to upload them onto the iPod.  Hence, the digital sound files residing on the iPod to be sold may very well be reproductions of the originally-purchased file.  If either the flash drive or the iPod were to be sold containing these reproductions, then the first sale doctrine cannot be applied.  However, if the original song owner were to sell his or her hard drive where the songs all were originally downloaded, this sale would presumably be within the first sale doctrine under the court’s reasoning.)

Turning back to the Second Circuit’s analysis, the court also held that ReDigi’s actions did not amount to fair use under test set forth in Section 107 of the Copyright Act, because the copying of the files was not transformative and essentially replaced the copyright owner’s marketplace for selling digital music files.

Finally, in closing the opinion, Judge Leval issues the time-honored sentiment that can be found in federal court opinions throughout history and across all areas of law:  If you have persuasive arguments to support a change in the law, then lobby Congress to codify those changes in statute, because the court cannot “substitute our judgment for that of Congress.”

Related Categories:

Copyrights

Firm Highlights

Insights

Minnesota Consumer-Fraud Enforcement: Disclaimers Won’t Cure Deception, and Penalties Can Add Up

Misleading advertising claims can lead to costly consequences. In State of Minnesota ex rel. Ellison v. Wall & Associates, Inc., No. A25-2064, 2026 WL 3118291 (Minn. App. Oct. 19, 2026), the Minnesota Court of Appeals recently affirmed a bench trial verdict against a tax-relief company and two executives for violations of the Minnesota Consumer Fraud Act (“MCFA”) and the Minnesota Deceptive Trade Practices Act (“MDTPA”). The decision, which affirmed a substantial restitution and civil penalty judgment, underscores the broad power of the Minnesota Attorney General to act against deceptive sales practices. The decision also offers practical lessons for businesses seeking to reduce liability risks in consumer-facing communications. Background Wall & Associates (“W&A”), a Virginia-based tax-relief company, marketed assistance to taxpayers seeking relief from outstanding federal and state tax liabilities, often with offers in compromise—agreements to settle tax liabilities for less than the amount owed. In its extensive advertising campaigns, W&A represented that its average client received a 90% reduction in their tax debt, that it was a local company with Minnesota offices, that it provided legal services, and that it would “Solve ALL Tax Problems.” In reality, W&A’s promises bore little resemblance to what many clients received. Most of W&A’s clients saw just a 9.5% reduction in federal tax debt and 1.2% in state tax debt. W&A had no permanent Minnesota offices. And W&A provided neither legal representation nor assistance with filing tax returns—those services required referrals to separate firms for an additional fee. All the while, W&A clients paid upfront and recurring fees, including during periods when W&A did no work on their cases. Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison sued W&A, its founder and owner Ernest Kenneth Wall, and its president and CEO Patrick Mark Yates, alleging violations of, among other laws, the MCFA and the MDTPA. Following a 12-day bench trial, the district court determined that W&A violated the MCFA and MDTPA through its false and embellished advertising. The district court also held Wall and Yates individually liable for those violations because they directed, participated in, and acquiesced in the violations. The district court ordered injunctive relief, $2.7 million in restitution (with Wall and Yates jointly and severally liable for $1.3 million), and civil penalties of $786,517 against W&A, $415,500 against Wall, and $207,750 against Yates. The district court also awarded over $2.5 million in attorneys’ fees and costs to the state. W&A, Wall, and Yates appealed to the Minnesota Court of Appeals, which affirmed the district court’s decision on October 19, 2026. Although W&A, Wall, and Yates challenged the judgment on numerous grounds, several highlights of the decision provide important takeaways for consumer-facing businesses. Individual Reliance Is Not Required for Statutory Liability W&A argued that Attorney General Ellison had to prove a causal nexus between each violation of the MCFA and MDTPA and the injury to a particular consumer to establish liability. In W&A’s view, this required proof that each injured consumer had personally relied on W&A’s false representation. The Court of Appeals rejected this argument based on the MCFA’s and MDTPA’s plain language, which requires no proof of actual deception or confusion by consumers. The Court of Appeals finally pointed to the Minnesota Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Minnesota School of Business, Inc., which held that when a defendant’s misrepresentations are directed at and affected “a broad group of consumers, proof of direct individual reliance is not required to establish a causal nexus between MCFA violations and the harm suffered by consumers.” 935 N.W.2d 124, 135 (Minn. 2019). The Court of Appeals affirmed, however, that a causal nexus is necessary to support an award of damages under the MCFA and MDTPA. In making that determination, district courts look to various factors, including whether the misrepresentations were “longstanding, pervasive, and widespread in communications directed to consumers,” whether the seller intended and understood that consumers would rely on the misrepresentations, and whether the information was of a kind on which consumers would typically rely. The Court of Appeals’ decision continues Minnesota School of Business’s broad interpretation of liability under the MCFA and the MDTPA. Coordinated marketing campaigns to a “broad group of consumers” may expose businesses to MCFA and MDTPA liability without customer-by-customer proof of injury. That said, a causal nexus remains an element of an MCFA and MDTPA claim, and businesses involved in litigation should build a clear record at trial and on appeal showing how each of the relevant factors bears on the causal-nexus inquiry. Contractual Disclaimers Are Not an Automatic Defense to a Misleading Pitch W&A next argued that disclaimers in its client contracts prevented consumers from claiming they had been misled by its advertising. Reiterating that individual reliance is not required under the MCFA and MDTPA, the Court of Appeals held that a contractual disclaimer does not necessarily defeat a claim based on a conflicting oral representation. And on the facts of this case, the Court of Appeals agreed with the district court that W&A’s contractual disclaimers were insufficient given the extensive misrepresentations by W&A and the unequal bargaining power between it and its customers. This holding confirms that contractual disclaimers are not a cure-all for misleading advertising or sales practices. Businesses should review the entire customer journey, including pre-contract representations, as those representations may survive a contractual disclaimer to the contrary. And if faced with litigation, businesses should build a strong record, both at trial and on appeal, showing why any disclaimer is effective in context. The State Has Broad Authority to Seek Restitution W&A also challenged Attorney General Ellison’s authority to seek restitution under the state’s parens patriae authority to protect residents’ collective interests, arguing that injury to only 228 Minnesotans did not affect a sufficiently substantial segment of the population. The Court of Appeals rejected a simple headcount approach, instead explaining that the state had a legitimate interest in protecting residents’ economic well-being as a whole. In any event, the Court of Appeals held that if restitution was not appropriate under the state’s parens patriae authority, then it would still be appropriate under the Attorney General’s enforcement powers under Minn. Stat. § 8.31. The decision reinforces that the broader and more sustained the deceptive advertising, the stronger the case for restitution to protect Minnesotans’ economic interests. Civil Penalties Accrue Per Violation, Not Per Defendant The Court of Appeals finally rejected W&A’s claim that the Attorney General’s enforcement powers under Minn. Stat. § 8.31 permit only civil penalties of up to $25,000 for each defendant. Rather, the Court of Appeals explained that penalties are limited to $25,000 per violation. Multiple violations can therefore produce substantially greater penalties. The Court of Appeals also rejected the argument that restitution made penalties unnecessary: repaying consumers does not eliminate the need to address gains from deceptive conduct and deter future violations. Final Takeaways Align every consumer-facing communication. Broad and extensive marketing campaigns can expose businesses to stronger enforcement standards under the MCFA and MDTPA, making it critical that consumer communications remain accurate and consistent from the first advertisement through the final sale. Plan for layered enforcement exposure. Penalties under the MCFA and MDTPA can add up quickly: W&A, Wall, and Yates ultimately faced more than $6 million in civil penalties, restitution, and attorneys’ fees. The decision continues a line of Minnesota cases recognizing the Attorney General’s broad consumer-protection authority. Details matter. Although the Attorney General’s enforcement power is broad, it is not boundless. As the Court of Appeals explained, issues of causation, the effectiveness of contractual disclaimers, and the availability of restitution and civil penalties all turn on the specific facts of the case. Effective advocacy at trial and on appeal is critical to developing the facts relevant to liability and damages.